Has Feminism gone too far?
March 15, 2023
A few of you reading this article may have seen the recent viral video where Chelsea Handler, a 47-year-old comedian, shares, satirically, what a day in the life of a single woman with no kids is like. This prompted a series of varying responses. The video comically portrays a lazy lifestyle, full of promiscuity and superficial happiness, with a strong emphasis on how good it is that she does not have kids. While it was meant to be satire, it does shed light some of the terrible ideologies that extreme feminism is leading women to buy into.
Extreme feminism is promoting to Westernised women that they live in a systematically patriarchal environment that is completely dominated by men. This lie is then convincing women that the only apparent way to overcome this terrible mountain of struggle is to shun the opposite gender and live a life of complete independence, which will in turn lead to the ultimate happiness of being an ‘empowered’ woman.
The problem with toxic feminism is that it is trying so hard to combat toxic masculinity that at times it goes as far as to villainise women who choose to have children as opposed to pursuing a career like their partner. However, I believe that while not all women are meant to have children, we should be celebrating women who choose to do so.
Candace Owens, an American Conservative author, talk show host and political commentator, even goes as far as to describe the rotten fruits that feminism is starting to produce in the US. She points out that birth rates in the US are continuing to decline and that nearly half of American women under 45 are childless, according to the New York Post. The article quotes:
“The study’s authors credit several reasons for the trends, including women obtaining higher levels of education as well as greater and longer career paths. The authors cited changing family values, financial concerns, improved access to contraception and relationship instability as additional reasons.”
I want to preface that I believe that women deserve to have equal opportunity in the workplace as they are just as important in the development of industries in our society. However, Candace Owens highlights here that the ‘War on Fertility’ has been in America since the 1970s. She believes that one of the lies promoted by extreme feminism is that being a mother and looking after kids at home is oppressive and gender stereotypical.
This is where the discussion of equality comes into play. What really is equality?
A toxic feminist would argue that equality is when women are the same as men in every aspect of their lifestyle. But this is where the message is misconstrued, toxic feminists are now pushing that women should not be “just” mothers and must have a career outside the home. Think about how many of these feminists have mothers of their own who devoted a large part of their life to raising and caring for them. Is all that their mother’s did for them in the name of a harsh and oppressive patriarchy, or in the name of the biologically engrained tendencies of love and nurture that women have towards children?
I’m not saying that the life of motherhood is for every woman, (just read 1 Corinthians 7 to learn about that from a Biblical perspective), but we know that motherhood is a blessing that is to be cherished, not downplayed.
Jordan Peterson summarises the lie that women are being sold by society very well;
“What our society does to 19-year-old women or 18-year-old women … we just lie to them all the time,” he said. “You know, the first lie is there’s nothing more important than your career, more or less by definition. So that’s the first lie. The second is there will be nothing more important to you in your life than your career. So that’s the second lie, and then the third lie is there should be nothing more important in your life than your career. So that’s the third lie.”
He goes on to point out other lies such as the lie that children are a burden and that having children is to give into the ‘patriarchal demand’ from an oppressive male-dominated government, to stay at home and be good housewives.
Careers and success and individuality should not be the defining feature of anyone’s life, but this is the message contemporary society is pushing out of fear of being labelled discriminatory or misogynistic. Women are beautifully created human beings with the capacity to give birth and care for new life, let them do that if they choose to do it well.
What defines us should be the love we show, the family we keep and the people who surround us that we have been a positive influence on.
So, how does toxic feminism impact men? That is a story for another day…
Links:
New York Post Article:
Candace Owens Article
- https://www.dailywire.com/news/the-u-s-birth-rates-decline-as-the-rotten-fruits-of-feminism-increase
Jordan Peterson Video
Abbey F • Mar 15, 2023 at 10:04 am
I appreciate your opinion and your right to have one, however, your comments on women choosing not to have children based on toxic feminism are flawed, along with your comment about the patriarchy not being real.
There are various reasons why women choose not to have children whether it be personal opinions, mental or physical health risks, their environment, or their financial capabilities. Also considering that in the US, women currently do not have the choice on whether or not they have a child if they conceive a fetus.
Additionally, women in Australia on average earn 15.8% less than a man. 1 in 2 mothers experience workplace discrimination after having a child, and 1 in 5 are made redundant, dismissed, or their contract was not renewed after becoming pregnant.
I would also like to point out the additional problems women face in the so-called ‘non-patriarchal’ world. There are 49 countries without laws on domestic violence, 45 countries without legislation on sexual harassment, and 112 countries where marital rape is not a crime. 1 in 3 women experience sexual violence in their lifetime. Every day over 800 women die due to complications with birth. 23% of women over the age of 18 have experienced some form of sexual violence, vs. 8% of men.
Yes, men are also victims of these problems however the inequality lies in how many MORE women experience it.
Gregorios • Mar 16, 2023 at 10:08 pm
I think this is a classic example of a strawman. Never once does the article assert the inexistence of the patriarchy or negate the struggle of women throughout time and across the globe.
Moreover, it is factually inaccurate that in the “US women currently do not have the choice on whether they have a child”. The overturning of Roe v Wade removed the right to abortion at a federal level and delegated the decision to the states (which was the law prior to 1973), meaning in states like California abortion is entirely legal even into the 3rd trimester. In fact, it is only ‘illegal’ in 11 out of 50 states, though measures do exist in place to protect mothers at risk etc.
Unfortunately, people see this article and have an emotional reaction, which is fair enough, but we all need to stand back and evaluate it based on its logic and merit. The world is much more complex than a black-and-white binary with such nuanced issues.
suhani S • Apr 4, 2023 at 3:26 pm
“Extreme feminism is promoting to Westernised women that they live in a systematically patriarchal environment that is completely dominated by men. This lie…” Stating that the male dominated patriarchy is a lie. Just saying.
Cameron F • Apr 17, 2023 at 9:01 pm
Yes you are correct, I did state the non-existence of a male dominated patriachy, but it is still important to recognise that I meant this in the context of the west as of the present. To say we live in a patriachy today, when we are possibly the most egalitarian society of all time is really interesting and I am always willing to hear someone’s arguments against it. I mean, Gina Rinehart seems to be doing pretty well for herself.
Ellina G • May 11, 2023 at 10:02 am
I think the obvious counterargument lies in the way you phrased your response, “we are possibly the most egalitarian society of all time”. Yes, it’s true – we as the west are one of the most egalitarian societies to date. However, just because we have gotten the furthest away from patriarchy doesn’t mean that we have gotten away from it. Feminism doesn’t “promote to women that they live in a systematically patriarchal environment” – life does. Feminism (or rather, concepts of Feminism. I personally think the word “feminism” has been tainted by societies perception) is simply the idea that all people, no matter gender, should be equal. How can that framework promote such an opinion? Saying this, feminism isn’t foolproof and everything to the extreme is, well, extreme. I think in your article you at times confused women that believe in equal rights (feminists by definitions) and women that hate men (what you label “extreme feminists” or how feminists are portrayed in the media). Happy to hear what you think of this.
Appreciate your opinion, student voice is important in all forms!
Mia M • Mar 27, 2023 at 10:02 am
additionally, men are also victims of crimes committed by men to men. according to the ABS “The new analysis found that police agencies in Australia recorded 53,570 sexual assault offenders between 2010-11 and 2019-20, with most of them male (97 per cent).”
Jacob G • Mar 15, 2023 at 8:50 am
Thanks for the article Cameron, your opinion is valued at WCC