Author’s Note: Welcome back to Disney vs Studio Ghibli, the series where I willingly pour my heart into analysing animated films while ignoring the fact that my Investigating Science trial exam is in less than an hour. Last time, we looked at love and discovered Disney believes in soulmates, while Studio Ghibli believes in labours of love. This time, we’re tackling something even more universal: growing up. After all, every Disney princess eventually leaves home, every Ghibli protagonist eventually learns something about themselves, and I’m still trying to figure out how taxes really work before I graduate in 4 weeks. So, who actually understands growing up better?
One of the greatest scams of childhood is being convinced that adulthood is a destination.
When we’re young, growing up seems wonderfully straightforward. Adults appear to know what they’re doing. They drive cars without accidentally ending up in another state. They pay bills. They answer phone calls. From a child’s perspective, adulthood looks less like a process and more like a promotion. You simply reach a certain age and become unc, unlock wisdom, and suddenly become one of the competent people.
However, I assume adulthood has the same energy as opening a group project and discovering everyone assumed somebody else knew what they were doing.
That disconnect between what we imagine growing up will be and what it actually feels like sits at the heart of countless children’s films. Disney and Studio Ghibli both return to the subject again and again, yet they seem fascinated by entirely different parts of the experience. Disney tends to view growing up as a journey towards the future. Its characters are dreamers, explorers, and rule-breakers who look beyond the horizon and believe something bigger is waiting for them. Studio Ghibli, by contrast, seems less interested in where its characters are going and more interested in who they become along the way. Disney asks how we change our lives. Ghibli asks how our lives change us.
Disney’s worldview is perhaps best captured by a recurring image that appears throughout its films: leaving home.
Ariel swims beyond the boundaries of her underwater kingdom. Rapunzel escapes her tower. Moana sails beyond the reef despite every warning telling her to stay where it’s safe. Even Simba’s journey in The Lion King revolves around leaving home and eventually returning as somebody new. For Disney, maturity often begins with crossing a boundary. There is always a forest to enter, a kingdom to discover, a boat to board, or, in Rapunzel’s case, an alarming amount of property damage involving frying pans.
These stories are compelling because they capture something genuinely exciting about adolescence. Growing up often feels like standing on the edge of a cliff overlooking the rest of your life. Everything is possible. Everything is potential. The future appears enormous. Disney understands that feeling beautifully. It understands what it means to ache for a world larger than the one you’ve known.
Nobody embodies this better than Moana. Unlike earlier Disney heroines, she isn’t motivated primarily by romance or rebellion. She’s driven by curiosity. The ocean calls to her for reasons she cannot fully explain, and much of the film’s emotional power comes from watching her learn to trust herself despite uncertainty. Her journey reflects a fundamental Disney belief: that growing up requires courage because the future is always unknown. You don’t become an adult by having all the answers. You become an adult by stepping into uncertainty anyway.
Yet Disney’s stories often end at the exact moment adulthood is supposed to begin.
The kingdom is saved. The dream is achieved. The protagonist discovers who they were meant to be. The credits roll. What happens next remains unclear.
Moana restores the heart of Te Fiti, but we never see her spending years governing alongside her people. Rapunzel reunites with her parents, yet we skip past the awkward conversations, difficult adjustments, and emotional recovery that would realistically follow eighteen years of imprisonment. Disney loves the moment of transformation because transformation is cinematic. It is much harder to build a musical number around gradually learning emotional resilience over the course of a decade.
This is where Studio Ghibli becomes fascinating because Miyazaki seems almost completely uninterested in dramatic transformations.
In fact, many Ghibli protagonists finish their stories as fundamentally the same people they were at the beginning. Chihiro remains shy. Sophie remains practical. Kiki stays awkward. What changes is not their identity but their understanding of themselves. Growing up in a Ghibli film rarely feels like becoming somebody new. It feels like gradually uncovering somebody who was already there.
Spirited Away shows this perfectly. Chihiro begins the story frightened, pessimistic, and deeply resistant to change. She does not want to move house. She doesn’t want to enter the spirit world. She certainly doesn’t want to spend the rest of the film working customer service in a version of hospitality infinitely more terrifying than anything found on Earth. Yet Miyazaki never presents her growth as a magical transformation. Chihiro develops because she is forced to confront challenges one at a time. She learns courage not through destiny but through practice.
That distinction feels important because it reflects the way people actually mature.
Most of us do not experience one life-changing event that suddenly turns us into responsible adults. We become adults through repetition. Through small acts of independence. Through making mistakes and surviving them. Through discovering that confidence often arrives after action rather than before it. Chihiro doesn’t become brave because she believes she can be brave. She becomes brave because circumstances continually require bravery from her.
My favourite example of this philosophy, however, is still Kiki’s Delivery Service.
On the surface, Kiki’s story sounds remarkably Disney-like. A young girl leaves home, ventures into a new world, and tries to discover herself. Yet the emotional focus of the film is completely different. Miyazaki spends surprisingly little time worrying whether Kiki will succeed. The audience already assumes she will. The more interesting question is how she handles the loneliness, exhaustion, and self-doubt that go with independence.
Halfway through the film, Kiki loses the ability to fly altogether. As a child, I interpreted this as a magical problem requiring a magical solution. As an older viewer, I find it alarmingly similar to burnout. Suddenly, the film becomes about something far more recognisable than witches or broomsticks. It becomes about losing confidence in something you once loved. It becomes about feeling disconnected from your own abilities. It becomes about the terrifying possibility that everybody else is thriving while you are quietly falling apart.
For a children’s film released in 1989, that’s an absurdly sophisticated understanding of growing up.
Even Howl’s Moving Castle, which holds shape-shifting wizards, walking fortresses, and enough magical nonsense to make the laws of physics file a formal complaint, approaches maturity in deeply human terms. Sophie’s curse transforms her into an old woman, but the brilliance of the film lies in what the curse symbolises. Long before the Witch of the Waste appears, Sophie already sees herself as insignificant. She assumes adventure belongs to other people. She limits herself before the world ever has a chance to.
As the film progresses, becoming physically older paradoxically allows her to become emotionally freer. Sophie stops worrying about how she’s perceived. She becomes more confident, more assertive, and more willing to occupy space within her own story. It is one of Miyazaki’s most beautiful ideas: that growing up is not necessarily about gaining something new. Sometimes, it is about shedding the fears that prevented us from becoming ourselves.
The more I compare the two studios, the more I think they are fascinated by different stages of the same journey. Disney captures our excitement about growing up. It understands ambition, possibility, and the irresistible pull of the future. Its protagonists look beyond the horizon and ask what kind of life they might build for themselves. Ghibli is more interested in what happens after the horizon is reached. It understands uncertainty, loneliness, resilience, and the quiet process of becoming comfortable with who you are.
If I had to choose which studio better understands growing up, I would probably give a slight edge to Studio Ghibli. Not because Disney is wrong, but because Ghibli recognises something adulthood eventually teaches all of us: there is no singular moment when you finally become grown up.
No fairy godmother arrives with your official certificate of maturity. No orchestra begins playing as you complete adulthood. If such a system existed, most of us would have failed the assessment the first time we tried assembling IKEA furniture.
Disney teaches us to look forward to growing up. Studio Ghibli teaches us to recognise it as it happens.
And perhaps, just like love, we need both.
We need Disney’s belief that life should have adventure, wonder, and enough optimism to make us step beyond our comfort zones. But we also need Ghibli’s reminder that maturity is not found in castles, kingdoms, or dramatic transformations. More often than not, it is found in everyday acts of courage nobody applauds. It is found in continuing despite uncertainty. In learning who we are. In becoming slightly wiser, slightly kinder, and slightly more comfortable with ourselves than we were before.
Perhaps that has always been Miyazaki’s point. Growing up is not about becoming a completely different person. It’s about becoming more completely yourself.




